This week, Extremely Little Liars finally leapt five years forward. While it was odd to see our girls all grown up in the Winter premiere, something terrible happens to put a damper on the aggregate. Shortly after her release back into the real world, Charlotte DiLaurentis is brutally murdered. Unraveling mysteries is no foreign concept on PLL — we desperately tried to figure out who “A” was for the first six ripens, after all — so it’s time to get cracking. Who killed Charlotte? Roll up your sleeves and observe reading for our top suspects.